Joint line tenderness
For: Meniscal tear
A tear of a meniscus, one of the two C-shaped cartilage pads between the femur (thigh bone) and the tibia (shin bone). It may follow a twisting injury or develop with age.
A weak test on its ownShort answer: On the published figures, a weak test on its own for meniscal tear. In the source cited below, sensitivity was 76% and specificity 77%.
How it is done
The patient lies supine with the knee flexed to about 90°. The examiner palpates systematically along the medial and lateral joint lines from front to back. Positive: Tenderness at the joint line itself, not over the collateral ligament above or below it.

What the numbers mean
- Positive result: a small shift: a positive result nudges the diagnosis up, but does not settle it.
- Negative result: a small shift: a negative result nudges the diagnosis down, but does not exclude it.
The ladder: what a result does to your estimate
| If you thought | After a positive | After a negative |
|---|---|---|
| 10% | 27% | 3% |
| 30% | 59% | 12% |
| 50% | 77% | 24% |
Calculated from the likelihood ratios above, as in the book. For any other starting estimate, use the probability calculator.
Work out what a result means for your patient: probability calculator
Likelihood ratios calculated from the pooled sensitivity and specificity. Checked against an open-access paper that tabulates the review (Kopf et al. 2020, Table 1) on 21 October 2026.
Do two examiners agree?
Slight (kappa 0.17, 95% CI -0.02 to 0.36; 92 patients, 1 study); two other studies also reported low agreement (abstract source only for Dervin 2001). Source: Snoeker 2015; Dervin 2001; Galli 2013.
Rule It In, Rule It Out gives the full reliability detail: every study, the same examiner versus two examiners, and the patients tested.
Study details: patients, setting, confidence intervals, what was read
| Study | Meserve 2008 (systematic review/meta-analysis) |
|---|---|
| Patients | 1,354 patients; pooled from 8 studies (n = 1,354 per the abstract); patient settings not described in what was read |
| Compared against | not stated in what was read |
| 95% confidence intervals | not given in the review we read, and the counts needed to calculate them are not available |
| Likelihood ratios | calculated from the sensitivity and specificity above |
| What we read | Open-access consensus paper that tabulates the meta-analysis's results; Meserve abstract (PMID 18212035; DOR 10.98, n = 1,354) plus Kopf et al. 2020 ESSKA meniscus consensus (PMC7148286, Table 1), which tabulates Meserve's joint line tenderness as 8 studies, sensitivity 76%, specificity 77%; Meserve full text paywalled (SAGE) |
| Things to bear in mind | Pooled estimate from 8 studies of poor to fair quality, and the review found that study quality changed the results. The abstract recommends future studies include more people without a tear, suggesting specificity is not well pinned down. |
How these details are gathered and checked: Methods.
Other tests in the library for meniscal tear
Compare all the tests for meniscal tear side by side
Red flags to screen for before testing the knee
Source
Meserve BB, Cleland JA, Boucher TR. A meta-analysis examining clinical test utilities for assessing meniscal injury. Clin Rehabil. 2008;22(2):143–161. PubMed · meta-analysis
Figures as they will appear in Rule It In, Rule It Out (Trokos, forthcoming). If a newer or better study changes them, this page changes with the book. Figures last updated from the book on 13 October 2026.
How to cite
Citing a figure? Cite the study it comes from. The main figures on this page come from:
Meserve BB, Cleland JA, Boucher TR. A meta-analysis examining clinical test utilities for assessing meniscal injury. Clin Rehabil. 2008;22(2):143–161.
Citing this page as a summary:
APA 7: Tompson, S. (2026, October 13). Joint line tenderness for meniscal tear. Trokos special tests library. Retrieved October 28, 2026, from https://trokos.com.au/tests/knee-jointlinetenderness.html
Vancouver: Tompson S. Joint line tenderness for meniscal tear [Internet]. Sunshine Coast (QLD): Trokos; 2026 [updated 2026 Oct 13; cited 2026 Oct 28]. Available from: https://trokos.com.au/tests/knee-jointlinetenderness.html
Citing the whole library:
APA 7: Tompson, S. (2026). Trokos special tests library (Version November 2026) [Online reference library]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23932041
Vancouver: Tompson S. Trokos special tests library [Internet]. Version November 2026. Geneva: Zenodo; 2026 [cited 2026 Nov 4]. Available from: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23932041
Get the book for the clinical reasoning behind each knee test it covers, and which ones to trust for the ACL, meniscus and kneecap
This page gives the published figures. Rule It In, Rule It Out adds captioned drawings with the exact positions, the Rule-In / Rule-Out bar and evidence dots, a fuller interpretation of each test, and the clinical reasoning on which tests to use and in what order.
Look inside the book: free sample pages
Coming November 2026: 330 pages, paperback and PDF. Launch offer: subscribers get the PDF for A$39 instead of A$49, for the first two weeks after publication. Be first to know at launch
One study, one test, once a month
Rule It In is a free evidence letter for musculoskeletal clinicians: one recent study explained, one examination test with its real numbers. From Trokos, publisher of Rule It In, Rule It Out.
Free when you confirm your email: a one-page PDF of the strongest special tests to rule in and rule out, with tests that carry a caution flagged separately.
Launch offer for subscribers: the PDF edition of Rule It In, Rule It Out for A$39 instead of A$49, for the first two weeks after publication. Sign up free to get the code on launch day.
By subscribing you agree to receive Rule It In by email, about once a month. You will get a confirmation email first, and nothing is sent until you click it. Your address is stored by Kit (Kit.com, United States) and used only for this newsletter and the subscriber launch offer; Kit records which issues are opened and which links are clicked. Unsubscribe with one click in any issue. Privacy.
