Clarke's sign (patellar grind test)
Also called: Clarke's test, patellar grind test
For: Chondromalacia patellae at arthroscopy (knees without patellofemoral pain)
Softening or damage of the articular cartilage on the back of the patella, as seen at arthroscopy. In this study the knees did not have patellofemoral pain.
Treat with caution (see below)Short answer: Treat results with caution when testing for chondromalacia patellae at arthroscopy (knees without patellofemoral pain): read the notes below before relying on one. In the source cited below, sensitivity was 39% and specificity 67%.
How it is done
With the knee extended, the examiner rests the web of the hand above the superior pole of the patella, presses gently downward and distally, and asks the patient to contract the quadriceps slowly. Positive: Pain behind the kneecap that stops the contraction being held.

What the numbers mean
- Positive result: barely informative: a positive result changes little.
- Negative result: barely informative: a negative result changes little.
The ladder: what a result does to your estimate
| If you thought | After a positive | After a negative |
|---|---|---|
| 10% | 12% | 9% |
| 30% | 34% | 28% |
| 50% | 55% | 48% |
Calculated from the likelihood ratios above, as in the book. Read the caution above before relying on these. For any other starting estimate, use the probability calculator.
Work out what a result means for your patient: probability calculator
Checked against the full paper: 9 of 23 knees with chondromalacia tested positive and 56 of 83 without it tested negative. Likelihood ratios as published (the abstract gives LR+ 1.18 and LR− 0.91; the text rounds them to 1.2 and 0.9).
Caution: Studied in people without patellofemoral pain; the authors recommended dropping the test.
Study details: patients, setting, confidence intervals, what was read
| Study | Doberstein 2008 (prospective validation study (single examiner, compared with arthroscopy)) |
|---|---|
| Patients | 106 patients (one knee each); patients of one surgeon (USA) booked for knee arthroscopy for problems unrelated to the kneecap, with no history of patellofemoral pain and no clinical or X-ray signs of patellofemoral injury |
| Compared against | arthroscopy (visual chondromalacia of the patella) |
| 95% confidence intervals | sensitivity 22–59%, specificity 57–77% (calculated from the study’s counts) |
| Counts | true positives 9, false positives 27, false negatives 14, true negatives 56 |
| Likelihood ratios | as published by the study |
| What we read | Full paper (J Athl Train 2008;43(2):190–196), Table 2 (2×2 counts: 9, 27, 14, 56; sensitivity 9/23 = 0.39, specificity 56/83 = 0.67, LR+ 1.18, LR− 0.91) |
| Things to bear in mind | Studied in people without kneecap pain who were already booked for keyhole surgery for something else, so it says nothing about the test in people who actually have patellofemoral pain. One examiner (the patients' own surgeon) did every test and the paper does not say the arthroscopy was done blind to the result. Only 23 of 106 knees had chondromalacia. The authors concluded the test should be dropped. |
How these details are gathered and checked: Methods.
Source
Doberstein ST, Romeyn RL, Reineke DM. The diagnostic value of the Clarke sign in assessing chondromalacia patella. J Athl Train. 2008;43(2):190–196. Journal article (DOI) · single study
Figures as they will appear in Rule It In, Rule It Out (Trokos, forthcoming). If a newer or better study changes them, this page changes with the book. Figures last updated from the book on 13 October 2026.
How to cite
Citing a figure? Cite the study it comes from. The main figures on this page come from:
Doberstein ST, Romeyn RL, Reineke DM. The diagnostic value of the Clarke sign in assessing chondromalacia patella. J Athl Train. 2008;43(2):190–196.
Citing this page as a summary:
APA 7: Tompson, S. (2026, October 13). Clarke's sign (patellar grind test) for chondromalacia patellae at arthroscopy (knees without patellofemoral pain). Trokos special tests library. Retrieved October 28, 2026, from https://trokos.com.au/tests/knee-clarke.html
Vancouver: Tompson S. Clarke's sign (patellar grind test) for chondromalacia patellae at arthroscopy (knees without patellofemoral pain) [Internet]. Sunshine Coast (QLD): Trokos; 2026 [updated 2026 Oct 13; cited 2026 Oct 28]. Available from: https://trokos.com.au/tests/knee-clarke.html
Citing the whole library:
APA 7: Tompson, S. (2026). Trokos special tests library (Version November 2026) [Online reference library]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23932041
Vancouver: Tompson S. Trokos special tests library [Internet]. Version November 2026. Geneva: Zenodo; 2026 [cited 2026 Nov 4]. Available from: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23932041
Get the book for the clinical reasoning behind each knee test it covers, and which ones to trust for the ACL, meniscus and kneecap
This page gives the published figures. Rule It In, Rule It Out adds captioned drawings with the exact positions, the Rule-In / Rule-Out bar and evidence dots, a fuller interpretation of each test, and the clinical reasoning on which tests to use and in what order.
Look inside the book: free sample pages
Coming November 2026: 330 pages, paperback and PDF. Launch offer: subscribers get the PDF for A$39 instead of A$49, for the first two weeks after publication. Be first to know at launch
One study, one test, once a month
Rule It In is a free evidence letter for musculoskeletal clinicians: one recent study explained, one examination test with its real numbers. From Trokos, publisher of Rule It In, Rule It Out.
Free when you confirm your email: a one-page PDF of the strongest special tests to rule in and rule out, with tests that carry a caution flagged separately.
Launch offer for subscribers: the PDF edition of Rule It In, Rule It Out for A$39 instead of A$49, for the first two weeks after publication. Sign up free to get the code on launch day.
By subscribing you agree to receive Rule It In by email, about once a month. You will get a confirmation email first, and nothing is sent until you click it. Your address is stored by Kit (Kit.com, United States) and used only for this newsletter and the subscriber launch offer; Kit records which issues are opened and which links are clicked. Unsubscribe with one click in any issue. Privacy.
