Special tests library › Elbow & forearm
Scratch collapse test
For: Cubital tunnel syndrome
Compression of the ulnar nerve as it passes behind the inside of the elbow (the 'funny bone'). It causes tingling or numbness in the ring and little fingers.
Treat with caution (see below)Short answer: Treat results with caution when testing for cubital tunnel syndrome: pooled figures, mostly from the developers' own clinic, suggest a positive test makes it much more likely (LR+ 27.4, calculated) and a negative test lowers it a little (LR− 0.40, calculated), but the only blinded independent study found the test no better than chance (sensitivity 10%, specificity 90%). It does not work for carpal tunnel syndrome.
How it is done
With both elbows bent, the patient pushes both forearms outwards against the examiner's hands (resisted shoulder external rotation). The examiner then lightly scratches the skin over the ulnar nerve on the inside of the elbow and straight away repeats the resisted outward push. Positive: a brief loss of resistance on the affected side, so the forearm gives way inwards (as described in the Cheng 2008 abstract and in Jain 2024; the patient's position, the exact elbow angle and how long to scratch are not confirmed).
What the numbers mean
- Positive result: see the caution above before relying on this result.
- Negative result: see the caution above before relying on this result.
The ladder: what a result does to your estimate
| If you thought | After a positive | After a negative |
|---|---|---|
| 10% | 75% | 4% |
| 30% | 92% | 15% |
| 50% | 96% | 29% |
Calculated from the likelihood ratios above. Read the caution above before relying on these. For any other starting estimate, use the probability calculator.
Work out what a result means for your patient: probability calculator
Sensitivity (60.5%) and specificity (97.8%) as printed in the Jain 2024 review (Table 3), which simply added together the results of 4 papers without a formal meta-analysis. Its printed counts are 149 true positives, 12 false positives, 97 false negatives and 530 true negatives. The likelihood ratios and their 95% confidence intervals are calculated from these counts, not printed (LR+ 0.6057 ÷ 0.0221 = 27.4; LR− 0.394 ÷ 0.978 = 0.40). The review cuts its percentages short rather than rounding them: 149 of 246 is 60.57%.
Caution: Most of the data come from the developers' own clinic, including a study that compared patients with a control group; one independent study is counted four times in the pooled figures; and the only blinded independent study found sensitivity 10% and specificity 90%, so a result told the examiner almost nothing (Montgomery 2020, abstract source only).
What the studies found
Cubital tunnel syndrome, checked with electrodiagnostic tests (nerve conduction studies, with or without EMG). Jain 2024 pooled 788 tests of arms from 4 papers: 246 had cubital tunnel syndrome, and the test picked up 149 of them (60.5%) and was negative in 530 of the 542 without it (97.8%) (LR+ 27.4, 95% CI 15.5–48.3; LR− 0.40, 0.35–0.47; calculated). These figures need care. The review's authors say most of the cubital tunnel data came from the developers' (Mackinnon) group, and call the data heavily biased by the surgeons who pioneered the test. The developers' original study compared 169 patients with 109 controls and reported sensitivity 69% for cubital tunnel syndrome, with no specificity figure in its abstract (Cheng 2008, abstract source only); its size is given differently in different sources (70 patients with cubital tunnel syndrome in its abstract, 331 arms in Jain 2024). The total of 788 is made up as 331 + 64 + 25 + 4 × 92 (calculated), so the 92 patients of the one independent study appear to be counted four times. That independent study (Montgomery 2020: 92 patients referred for electrodiagnostic testing, with both examiners blinded; abstract source only) found sensitivity 10% and specificity 90% for cubital tunnel syndrome, so a result changed the probability hardly at all (LR about 1, calculated), and agreement between examiners was poor (kappa −0.025, worse than chance, and 0.211, fair; on this scale 0 is chance agreement and 1 is perfect). A small study that measured the push with a dynamometer (a strength gauge), in 16 patients and 20 healthy volunteers, found sensitivity 37% and specificity 75% (LR+ 1.48, LR− 0.84, calculated; Anantavorasakul 2026, abstract source only). The test does not work for carpal tunnel syndrome: an independent meta-analysis of 3 studies (165 patients) found LR+ 0.75 and LR− 1.03 (Huynh 2018, full paper).
Study details: patients, setting, confidence intervals, what was read
| Study | Jain 2024 (systematic review that added together the 2×2 tables of 4 papers; no formal meta-analysis) |
|---|---|
| Patients | 788 tests of arms (246 with cubital tunnel syndrome) from hand surgery and electrodiagnostic clinics, mostly the developers' clinic; the 92 patients of one study appear to be counted four times, and both arms of a patient were counted separately |
| Compared against | electrodiagnostic tests (nerve conduction studies, with or without EMG); in the developers' study the diagnosis also used the history and examination |
| 95% confidence intervals | none printed; calculated from the printed counts: sensitivity 54.3–66.5%, specificity 96.2–98.7%, LR+ 15.5–48.3, LR− 0.35–0.47 |
| Likelihood ratios | calculated from the counts printed in Jain 2024 (Table 3) |
| What we read | Jain 2024 and Huynh 2018: full papers. Cheng 2008, Montgomery 2020 and Anantavorasakul 2026: abstracts only. |
| Things to bear in mind | The review did not assess the quality of the studies it pooled. It labels the developers' study as 2017 but cites the 2008 paper. The review's authors suggest that the examiner's experience matters a lot. |
How these details are gathered and checked: Methods.
Red flags to screen for before testing this region
Source
Jain NS, Zukotynski B, Barr ML, Cortez A, Benhaim P. The scratch-collapse test: a systematic review and statistical analysis. Hand (N Y). 2024;19(7):1054–1061. PubMed Central
Also cited: Cheng CJ, Mackinnon-Patterson B, Beck JL, Mackinnon SE. Scratch collapse test for evaluation of carpal and cubital tunnel syndrome. J Hand Surg Am. 2008;33(9):1518–1524. PubMed
Also cited: Montgomery K, Wolff G, Boyd KU. Evaluation of the scratch collapse test for carpal and cubital tunnel syndrome – a prospective, blinded study. J Hand Surg Am. 2020;45(6):512–517. PubMed
Also cited: Huynh MNQ, Karir A, Bennett A. Scratch collapse test for carpal tunnel syndrome: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. 2018;6(9):e1933. PubMed Central
Also cited: Anantavorasakul N, Duangmee I, Honglertkawin S, Siripoonyothai S, Kittithamvongs P, Malungpaishrope K, et al. Objective evaluation of the ‘scratch collapse test’ for the diagnosis of cubital tunnel syndrome using dynamometer. J Hand Surg Am. 2026;51(1):61.e1–61.e5. PubMed
Website only: not in the book.
Figures checked against the sources cited above, in a check separate from the drafting; any note above says where only the abstract could be checked. If a newer or better study changes them, this page will be updated.
How to cite
Citing a figure? Cite the study it comes from. The main figures on this page come from:
Jain NS, Zukotynski B, Barr ML, Cortez A, Benhaim P. The scratch-collapse test: a systematic review and statistical analysis. Hand (N Y). 2024;19(7):1054–1061.
Figures quoted in the notes from other studies are cited under Source above.
Citing this page as a summary:
APA 7: Tompson, S. (2026, November 16). Scratch collapse test for cubital tunnel syndrome. Trokos special tests library. Retrieved November 16, 2026, from https://trokos.com.au/tests/elbow-scratchcollapse.html
Vancouver: Tompson S. Scratch collapse test for cubital tunnel syndrome [Internet]. Sunshine Coast (QLD): Trokos; 2026 [updated 2026 Nov 16; cited 2026 Nov 16]. Available from: https://trokos.com.au/tests/elbow-scratchcollapse.html
Citing the whole library:
APA 7: Tompson, S. (2026). Trokos special tests library (Version November 2026) [Online reference library]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23932041
Vancouver: Tompson S. Trokos special tests library [Internet]. Version November 2026. Geneva: Zenodo; 2026 [cited 2026 Nov 16]. Available from: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23932041
Get the book for deciding which elbows need an X-ray after a fall, and whether the distal biceps is torn
Rule It In, Rule It Out covers the tests it includes in its ‘The elbow’ chapter: how to do each one, what counts as positive, and how to read the result.
Look inside the book: free sample pages
Coming November 2026: 330 pages, paperback and PDF. Launch offer: subscribers get the PDF for A$39 instead of A$49, for the first two weeks after publication. Be first to know at launch
One study, one test, once a month
Rule It In is a free evidence letter for musculoskeletal clinicians: one recent study explained, one examination test with its real numbers. From Trokos, publisher of Rule It In, Rule It Out.
Free when you confirm your email: a one-page PDF of the strongest special tests to rule in and rule out, with tests that carry a caution flagged separately.
Launch offer for subscribers: the PDF edition of Rule It In, Rule It Out for A$39 instead of A$49, for the first two weeks after publication. Sign up free to get the code on launch day.
By subscribing you agree to receive Rule It In by email, about once a month. You will get a confirmation email first, and nothing is sent until you click it. Your address is stored by Kit (Kit.com, United States) and used only for this newsletter and the subscriber launch offer; Kit records which issues are opened and which links are clicked. Unsubscribe with one click in any issue. Privacy.
